PANTHER LAW
Legal Clinic of Naira Renault (Naira R. Matevosyan), MD, MSJ, PhD


A medical doctor, jurist, scientist, former Regional Exchange Scholar at GWU/American Council (2000), CIDA fellow (ON 2002, MB 2007), Hubert Humphrey & Fulbright Scholar at Emory/CDC (2005-2006), principal investigator & postdoc at BU (2008-2010), American-Austrian Foundation awardee - the Open Medical Institute of Salzburg (1998, 2000, 2007), George Soros (OSI) Foundation awardee (1998, 1999, 2000, 2007), FedBar member, partner with New European Surgical Academy (NESA)/Berlin (Germany), Thurgood Marshall moot court judge, author of 176 multi-genre bestselling books (pen names - Naira Matevosyan, Naira R. Matevosyan, Naira Roland Matevosyan, Naira R.M, Naira Renault, Naira Roland Renault), well-cited scholar (70+ papers with Springer Verlag and Willey), program manager and speaker (IPPF/Brussels/Belgium, AUDEM/Belgrade/Serbia, Albert Schweitzer Institute), trainee at the AKH/Vienna, CEU/Budapest, Debrecen MU, Charles University of Prague, McMaster (ON), graduate of Seton Hall University School of Law (NJ), singer, poet, pianist, composer, avid traveler, designer, content single mother (the highest award).
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
---|
GETTING STARTED: Submit your inquiry, issue, or lecture invitation in the "Contact Us" section and we will respond within 24 hours. After the initial intake, we will determine the forms you need to download from the "Forms & Updates" section. Visit the navigation menu on top for clarity.
​
HOURS OF OPERATION: 24/5, Tuesdays - Saturdays,
including the National, secular, and religious holidays.
​
SERVICES: Legal or medical-legal RAFF (Risk Assessment, Forensic, Forecast). Assessment of the case harbors and drawbacks, discovery, pre-trial preparation or enhancement. Preparing research proposals, IRB materials, forensic analysis and reports, editing, proofreading. Lectures in malpractice law, health law, patent law, trademark law, Stark law, biotech law, conflicts of laws, maternal-fetal medicine, high-risk pregnancies, epidemiology, biostatistics, immunology.
​
NOTE: We do not provide legal representation. Accordingly, our activities are not barred by the State Sovereign Immunity Clause of the 11th Amendment or the Ripeness Clause. We consult but do not counsel.

Registration # 13234692
SCOPE:
- MEDICAL /SURGICAL MALPRACTICE
- THE LAW OF PATIENT CARE & FAULT DOCTRINES
- CORPORATE COMPLIANCE:
STARK (42 U.S.C. § 1395nn), AKS (42 U.S.C. §1320a-7b),
FCA (31 U.S.C. § 3729)
- INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW:
(15 U.S.C., 17 U.S.C., 35 U.S.C.)
- MATERNAL-FETAL MEDICINE
- EUCLID EPIDEMIOLOGY, BIOSURVEILLANCE, BIOMETRICS
- FORENSICS
Trademark (TM) 2016 - 2026 ( 15 U.S.C. § 1111, Sec.29 )
Copyright © 2016 - 2086 + ( 17 U.S.C. § 105 )
Free medical consultations in obstetrics & gynecology on doctorbase.com
This website was opened in July 2016, after my graduation from Seton Hall School of Law (Newark, NJ). It was never meant to be a "grievance board." Instantly after launching it, this effort too, was assassinated by the BANDITS below, after they had ruined my medical career by their stalking and wicked defamation (online, offline). Eventually, they wanted to have this website removed as well. And who are they? Neither doctors, nor lawyers, nor scientists, nor basic researchers, nor reasonable humans. They are the empty vessels of evil, as well as banal CRIMINALS, aboriginal sadists, anomalous misanthropes who are perpetually engaged in vandalizing and demonizing images of others. These are Armenian immigrants (unlawfully stayed in the US) and I wish it were the only "essential" thing about them... Details follow.
BRIEFLY ABOUT THE ORGANIZED ARMENIAN HEINOUS TERROR AGAINST ME:
The term "terror" wasn't my own characterization of the ongoing. It was a Dekalb County Magistrate Judge who, evaluating the case on 12/03/2014, named these offenders (Karine Martirosyan, Marina Noble, Ara Khachatryan) "TERRORISTS" (click the sage weblink) and sent the case to Dekalb Felony division where the case rested as these criminals found ways to influence my police from MA to GA , just like they attempted to "deprive me of motherhood" in 2017, for my a real estate property (a long story), and for that they maliciously initiated "child neglect" cases against me, Faxmiling from MA to GA any kind of diabolic madness to influence my local DFCS - unsuccessfully though - when my exemplary motherhood is the vertical opposite of their HIDEOUS LIES. On top of being a doting single mother, I have also been my son's online school's full-time home teacher (24/7) for 8 disciplines and 3 languages from his 3rd grade to the 12th. I used my hardship years (unemployed because of their defamation) for my son's benefit. My son graduated high school (with A grades) in 2021, age 18, and was admitted to a college the same year (2021). These HARASSING MONSTERS would NEVER be able to sit their children in the roles of 24/7 home-school teachers, as they deeply lack intellect, let alone their psychosis, rudeness, and vulgarity.
After my privileged life (an ob/gyn doctor with extensive practice, manager of 12 public health programs, recognized scientist and recurrent awardee of dozens of science and travel grants -- click the light sage hyperlinks for evidence), I started a promising career in the USA as a principal investigator/postdoc at Boston University, published scientific works (without BU's awareness or support) which were well regarded and cited by peer scientists, and successfully adjusted my status (by self-petition) based on the awarded meritorious NIW category that is being issued only to 6% of the applicants ("individuals with advanced degrees and exceptional skills in the U.S. National interest", click here). Since then, the STALKING, BARBARIC, DIABOLIC Armenian misanthropes intensified their defamatory and discrediting campaign against me and my child. Naming them "TERRORISTS," on 12/03/2014 a Dekalb County (GA) Magistrate Judge, sent the case to the CID felony division. The third and most determined waive of their aforethought malice restarted after they learned that I was admitted by Emory Law in 2013 . They then bombarded the Internet, naming me a "liar," a "wannabe lawyer", confessing to contacting "Emory Law professors" to slander and libel me. Secretively from their STALKING eye, I changed law school (for lower tuition) and earned my law degree (MSJ) from Seton Hall University School of Law (Newark, NJ).
The vicious TERRORISTS are Marina (Mkhitaryan) Noble in MA (DOB 06/01/1966), Karine M. Martirosyan in MA (DOB 10/22/1966), Paul E. Noroian in MA (MOB 03/1965), Ara Khachatryan (DOB 11/07/1969 ) in Brooklyn(NY) and now fled to Hackettstown (NJ) who have formed an ARMENIAN "alliance" (their term) to sink me. The "mentor" of this heinous terror is a dross peasant Karine Martirosyan (an unpolished and vulgar narcissist) whose face you can see below on this site next to the issued FOUR ARREST WARNINGS against her and her trolls. Born in Spitak/Armenia, she became my lifetime curse and plague that stalks me NON-STOP for three decades. Karine did not have a roof until her 40 years and was sleeping in undergraduate student dorms in the 2nd Massiv District of Yerevan. Among the immense harm she has caused to my life and career, she also lies to the website owners (where my professional profiles are held) - achieving the removal of so many facts that are shameful for her, including true and exact copies of my court files (non-classified cases) that are at public access in the court portals. Most importantly, she (and her hooligan friend Marina Noble- forer Mkhitaryan) started harming me even before we moved to the USA. Specifically, she was caught several times composing fake ad "negative" reference letters against me, and sneakily submitting those (via unidentifiable emails and Faxmail) to my potential employers -- each time she would stalk and learn that I was about to start a job with a higher salary and position than hers (the Kosovo case of 2001 is just one example). I reserve the detailed reporting of countless events in my upcoming book of memoirs.
In the U.S., the above-listed BANDITS restarted another decade of orchestrated lynching by:
(1) publishing THOUSANDS of defamatory forums against me - titled under my full name so their libels will pop-up with the search of my name (some saved screenshots of the removed ones are here, a documentary that they are dying to remove); (2) cyber-bullying my precious son for NO REASON but their toxic and sick jealousy as one can imagine the thickness of bloody malice that Marina Noble and Karine Martirosyan suffer due to their unpresentable chi; (3) criminally libeling my dead parents (extremely moral, elegant physicians) because none of these hooligans has sprung from a healthy normal or decent family; (4) spreading ludicrous disinformation about me, fabricating non-existent "criminal records" with my name photoshopped and inserted; (5) HARASSING father of my child, contacting his faculty at the GWU with disparaging and false statements about me, and bragging about their suchly communications in their posts (now removed by them; the saved screenshots of their complaintsboard.com posts as well as Facebook declarations are with court files, and also can be viewed here); in addition, contacting my former coworkers at BU and bragging about it in their nasty, offensive posts; (6) attacking my over 175 multi-genre books which I wrote (and ilustrated) in a decade of a non-income hardship, maliciously misleading my readers that I do not author those books" (they neither have intellectual horizons nor sparks, nor they can write two words - without stealing ideas; therefore, they think so poorly about me based on their cognitive-dissonance-psychosis); (7) contacting my remote "relatives" (who fight for the properties willed on my child) and offering them their help (read the page-2 of the court order pre-written by their lawyer which the senie (82y/o) judge signed in front of me without even reading to notice that his name was misspelled, and whichdemands [all] my properties in [anywhere in the world] (ad verbatic); (8) flooding the Internet with defamatory and lengthy posts (now removed by them) as if "half of my 80+ scientific publications are not mine, as Naira Roland Matevosyan and Naira R. Matevosyan are different persons" [sic] - when in the reality, both are me (Roland was my dad); my published science works deeply pain these hooligans who do not have any pubication but Internet vulgar posts; (9) using the same concocted bitter conspiracy theories to make ResearchGate admin thrice remove my RG profile together with my high RG-score and over 280 citations of my works, so each time I will restart from zero; note that the corrupt RG fabricates LIES as if my former score was 29 as opposed to 281; (10) with the same malign intent, attacking doximity.com, wix.com or academia.edu admins - to have my profiles removed from the search results (note, the site analytics clearly show their attacking patterns); (11) publishing SCAM "herpes advice " blogs (see the removed content on pp. 3-5 of the 9-page document) in various websites - in intentionally unhinged, ridiculous, incoherent language, and falsely confessing therein (under my name) to "having g. herpess" - an incurable chronic infection I NEVER HAD ; (12) contacting the law schools where I applied or graduated, to prevent me earning degree (then confessing about it in their posts through 2015-2017); (13) after learning that they failed in that particular malignant effort, filing eodem tempore (simultaneously) several phony, fallacious "lawsuits" (claiming "emotional distress") at various courts in MA and GA and commiting the FELONY crime of PERJURIOUS AFFIDAVITS filed in the courts (which the bribed judges normalize); (14) creating "ready keywords" for the search engines where they link my name with the word "scam," and (15) CONTINUING to libel/slander me and my child AFTER their lawsuits, which gives them the fitting name of TERRORISTS; (16) ROBBING THE I.R.S. by using the illegally obtained, unconstitutional orders based on "emotional distress" fallacy and non-existent "damages" (see the two INSANE , UNRPOFESSIONAL, MESSY orders here - page 2, and here) to file INCOME TAX CREDIT as MISC1099 "punitive damages and legal settlement awards" and by that receiving more than $200,000.00 income credit- returns per year as their puntivie "damages" have growing interest rates . Not only they accused ME of libeling THEM (when factually, they are my inferiors academically, culturally, by looks, by degree, by pedigree - thus, I would hate to see my name linked to theirs) but they accused me of things they actually have DONE to me! Below see round icons of the utterly corrupt courts where I fought alone (pro se). CLICK THE VIDEO.
TO VIEW THE COURT FILES (PRO SE - ME, AS MY OWN ATTORNEY), CLICK THE ROUND ICONS. BE MINDFUL THAT THE LINKS TO WEBSITES WITH STORED FILES ARE PERIODICALLY BROKEN AND THE WEBSITES DEMOLISHED BY THESE BANDITS (TO THE RIGHT) WHO CONTACT THOSE SITES (issuu.com, scribd.com) ASKING TO REMOVE MY FILES. THEY CONCEAL THE TRUTH SO THEIR FALSE NARRATIVE WILL DOMINATE.
ARREST WARRANTS against Karine Martirosyan (DOB 10/22/1966), Ara Khachatryan (DOB 11/07/1969 or 1968), Marina Mkhitaryan Noble (MOB 06/1966 or 1967), William R.Noble (DOB 09/20/1962)
Goes to the SCOTUS. The diabolic villains will get a fitting punishment.
S20C1199
GA Supreme Court
Certiorari
A19A1659
GA Court
of Appeals
Search the 2-year history of my fight (pro se) at Dekalb Superior Court, where I recused 3 judges: Input Docket 17CV8129
Motion 1 (Dismiss):
2081CV01227
Middlesex
County Superior
Court, MA
Motion 2 (Reply):
2081CV01227
Middlesex
County Superior
Court, MA
Framingham District Court (MA). On page-20 of the linked document see SCHIZOPHRENIC Karine Martirosyan's unhinged hand-printed complaint reporting my SSN which she knows since 2010.
MA Court of Supreme Justices: Case
Reply 2 Opposition
Opposing money demands
2021-P-0388
Advance Notice of Appeal
2081CV01227
Middlesex
County Superior
Court, MA
Last Notice of Appeal
2081CV01227,
after the last crazy order:
Middlesex
County Superior
Court, MA
FRAUD Discovery Motion & MEMO
2081CV01227,
Middlesex
County Superior
Court, MA
The number 6th notice of Direct Appeal. The peasant slut Karine Martirosyan hates you to see it, as she asks the websites to quarantine it:
2081CV01227
Middlesex, MA
Motion 4 (Vacate):
2081CV01227
Middlesex
County Superior
Court, MA
Motion 3 (Recuse):
2081CV01227
Middlesex
County Superior
Court, MA
Framingham Court's SCAM:
2049AC001177-SU
Upon the psycho Karine Martirosyan's bombardier of several courts with primitive, factless soap-operas spanning a period of 20 years, this court sent me a Notice with a DEAD clerks' name (John A. DeLuca) who had passed on 08/01/2020. Despite, the notice was dated 10/14/2020. SHAME !
​
Discretionary appeal
2081CV01227
Singe Justice
Amended Notice
of Appeal
2081CV01227
Middlesex
County Superior
Court, MA
Motion 5 (Mistrial):
2081CV01227
Middlesex
County Superior
Court, MA
Notice of Appeal
2081CV01227
Middlesex
County Superior
Court, MA
Appellant Brief: MA Appeals Court
2021-P-0388
Appellant Brief: MA Appeals Court
2021-P-0388
MING SOON: I look for excuses to procrastinate the writing of a memoir (documentary) as it will be a painful journey, pulling me back to the heinous hell - plotted by these ANIMALS above. Somebody has to hold my hand while I am writing that book. Further, humiliating myself by writing about them (and by that making them "famous") isn't an attractive option. However, I WILL write that book, as my son wants the truth and reality to be liberated from the diabolic smear and disinformation PLAGUE that these thugs have coated me with. Therein, I will also describe (by facts and corroboration) what desperate PROSTITUTES were Karine Martirosyan and Marina Noble (Marine Mkhitaryan) in their native country as well as in Kosovo, technically begging men for sex/money/shelter and being rejected over and over again. The random visitors of this site would be astonished that we all (age > 50) are still talking about such trivia. This wasn't my choice or my conventional "theme." Each time these stalkers observe my life improvements (which they hysterically sweat to prevent - details will be in my book, until then click the red link to watch some video evidence- only some), they attack by phony/fallacious lawsuits based on their delusional, pointless spins and smears - to assassinate my character. They attack defensively and preventively. I used not to care how these animals (above) make a fool of every American by erasing their embarrassing pasts and selling themselves by bold lies and manic grandeur. Now, I have to disclose their true ugly faces (by lowering myself at their level). My court papers are strictly narrowed to legal measures. Hence, a book will be a fitting platform for articulating the events of the last two decades. We'll see HOW FAR THEIR STUPIDITY WILL GO.
To the right, see the scanned copy of a fake, fabricated email (from so-called "Ingrid Li") in a "forwarded" mode, presented at the Middlesex Superior Court (Woburn, MA, Docket 2081CV01227) by the criminal fraudsters from MA (Paul Noroian and Karine Martirosyan a/k/a Kar Martirosyan, a/k/a Karina Martirosyan, a/k/a Karine M. Martirosyan, a/k/a Karine Martirosyian) to show a "third party observation of a defamatory post" which they godlessly accuse me of. My problems with that email: (1) The header shows yahoo.com domain (from where the content was "forwarded"), yet the email was sent-received between verizon.net and state.ma.us domains. (2) If indeed, Paul Noroian received this email from a "colleague" (Ingrid Li) and found it important "third party" evidence, why did he NOT keep that direct email from Ingrid Li and rather "forwarded it to his wife, Karine" and then showed his forwarded email to the court? Very simple: (a) people concoct falsehood in the email forwarding mode, (b) the email (from Ingrid Li) DOES NOT exist; (c) in forwarded mode, it is hard to track down the IP source. (3) Paul Noroian identifies himself as a MA state employee, yet in none of the court files he reports being one. (4) The header shows yahoo.com because this is FABRICATED by Karine Martirosyan (on her kmartirosyan@yahoo.com account) on behalf of her husband. (5) Would one believe that a "forensic psychiatrist" Ingrid Li was waiting at the bus stop to get to the job and "saw Paul Noroian driving through and then googled to see... " See what? Unhinged nonsense ! (6) This CROOKED Armenian couple endlessly rants about their "endangered physical safety" for non-threatening Internet posts that I haven't even written (and when I live 1000 miles away). Yet, they easily shared in the public-access court-portal the name of Ingrid's child (Kyla Guay). (7) The language of the email ("horrible post" or "BTW") is typical of Karine Martirosyan. (8) This forwarded scam is Karine Martirosyan's criminal M.O. When she ruined my Kosovo job offer by reference FRAUD, self-Faxmailing her fabrication, trimming the data of transaction ID and showing it to the DOWUSA (by which I lost USD $60,000.00 in 2002) I thought that was her worst harm. I had no idea that she would sextuple down her bold falsehood in the future. She attacks me first each time (to benefit from the first mover privilege) when I understand her crimes. The alleged email from Ingrid Li was sent on 05/31/2019, yet they filed the lawsuit on 05/22/2020. Why? Because would this email be questioned, she would say that emails older than a year are automatically deleted on the state.ma.us portal. (9) I have NEVER EVER used any internetchecheker.com site ! Today, searching that address, I found out that that site is for sale. So, this CRIMINAL woman (Karine) has calculated all angles before fabricating that fake email in "forwarded mode" as an "evidence exhibit." (10) This pattern reconfirms Karine's Kosovo fraud.
Karine Martirosyan has gotten away with so many crimes (so did her crime-friend, Marina Noble from Watertown/MA, who has now fled to San Diego/CA). But not this time! I did not work hard my entire life or earn so many degrees to let these hooligans ruin me with primitive fraud tricks.
There's a reason why Paul Noroian (whose face U will never find on the web as he is self-conscious) moved from Westborough (MA) to live in Hopkinton (MA). A disgraced police "informer", documented liar, false accuser, a notorious perjuror, he was ruining innocent people in his community and beyond. Further, he ceased his practice as a "psychiatrist" after he was charged with a federal crime (breach of the False Claim Act, 31 U.S.C. 3729(b)C). In his practice years, he would prescribe dreadfully addictive drugs to his patients without a minimum exam for etiology or comorbid. Where the treatment failed, he would double or triple the doses. He would make DUI cases of his harmed patients, handle them to police, have them charged/arraigned, then he would emerge to "save them from prison to mental rehab"(for money split between police and hooligan judges). That is why all his false accusations are blindly intaken by his local police without vetting for falsehood, fallacy or actual malice. He is a team with his local police (first in Westborough, now in Hopkinton). To the right see a fake email he reported to the court (Middlesex, 2081CV01227) to concoct a "third party" seeing a post that I had not even written or placed. The obvious SCAM in the email (to the right) is the yahoo.com domain (consumed by his wife Karine ) forwarding a fake email from mass.state.gov domain. The criminals always compose falsehood via an email "forwarding" mode:

This horrible crime was committed on 07/28/2020 (on the 3rd "anniversary" of Marina Noble's lawsuit and at the time when I was filing a pro se Certiori at GA Supreme Court while also addressing another phony-smearing publicity lawsuit brought by the criminal Karine Martirosyan (cowardly in her state, MA). I noticed this site only on 02/18/2023 as before it would not show up by Google search of my name. That site was "updated" by them on 01/18/2023- probably to make it visible and indexed when the time bar (for tort) is effective. These skilled IT criminals know how to play with timelines. The saved screenshot of that SCAM page is to the right:
​
​


There is more behind these lawsuits with money robbery. These bolsheviks above are also attacking my inheritance (real estate from my parents - the last reality check of my splendid life prior to their terror), to erase my identity. Their goal is plainly expressed on page 2- of this order. As you read this, they continue contacting each and every of my neighbors, colleagues, former coworkers or former classmates to demonize and discredit me to safe their faces; they continue to file more lawsuits and complaints to CONFISCATE my fundamental right (free, non-violent, non-threatening speech) guaranteed by Supreme Laws which I use to protect my life, my son, our honor. Not all files are shared. For a deeper picture, I uploaded the exact and true copies of my 49 files at the courts above (containing evidence, facts, dates) in one profile ( slideshare.net/nairarenault/documents) which has been recently suspended by these criminals above, to safe their shameless faces (as the truth and evidence therein were incompatible with their false narratives). So, I had to open other sites to re-upload my files. Withal, if the court cases (like these) are free for public access, then I don't see why I cannot publicly share the EXACT and TRUE copies of my own files- as they are in the court portals?
UPDATE on 11/19/2020: ANOTHER FRAUD !
I just saw a fake website that has copied-pasted fragments to impersonate my legal clinic: https://www.juridipedia.com/XX/Unknown/1779061662373967/Panther-Law%2C-LLC
By scamming under the Trademark of my business, and shaming with "one five-star like" to create false optics, the SCAMMERS then ask to "contact" - to study the nature of communications I usually receive (through that scam site). Please DISREGARD https://www.juridipedia.com/XX/Unknown/1779061662373967/Panther-Law%2CLLC
which has NOTHING to do with my activities. DO NOT CONTACT that site at all. Be mindful that there can be TONS of similar SCAMS.
CONTACT US
FILL-IN YOUR PRIMARY INQUIRY:
Briefly about Naira:
The George Washington University
Springer PubMed Semantic Scholar CV
Linkedin.com Scholar.Google.com WBP Academia ORCiD SlideShare.net
Gallery of Publications Doximity
